Running Costs: Natural Gas vs Propane vs Diesel
Per-hour and per-day fuel costs at 50% and 100% load for every common kW rating. Real numbers with a calculator, not vague ranges.
Running Cost Comparison
Costs at 50% load (typical during an outage) and 100% load. Most generators run at 30 to 60 percent load during a real outage.
| Size | Fuel | $/hr (50%) | $/hr (100%) | $/day (50%) | $/day (100%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 10 kW | Natural gas | $0.94 | $1.89 | $11.31 | $22.62 |
| 10 kW | Propane | $2.00 | $4.00 | $24.03 | $48.06 |
| 16 kW | Natural gas | $1.45 | $2.90 | $17.40 | $34.80 |
| 16 kW | Propane | $3.07 | $6.14 | $36.85 | $73.69 |
| 22 kW | Natural gas | $2.03 | $4.06 | $24.36 | $48.72 |
| 22 kW | Propane | $4.27 | $8.54 | $51.26 | $102.53 |
| 48 kW | Natural gas | $3.99 | $7.97 | $47.85 | $95.70 |
| 48 kW | Propane | $8.54 | $17.09 | $102.53 | $205.06 |
Based on recent EIA residential fuel prices: natural gas about $1.45/therm (latest EIA monthly, ~$15/thousand cubic feet), propane about $2.67/gallon (last EIA heating-season survey). Actual costs vary by region and supplier.
Running Cost Estimator
Per-hour fuel cost at 50% load (typical outage load). Multiply by run hours for daily and weekly cost.
INPUTS
DAILY FUEL COST
$24.36
$2.03 / hour at 50% load
Fuel Consumption Rates
| Size | NG @ 50% | NG @ 100% | LP @ 50% | LP @ 100% |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 10 kW | 65 cu ft/hr | 130 cu ft/hr | 0.75 gal/hr | 1.5 gal/hr |
| 16 kW | 100 cu ft/hr | 200 cu ft/hr | 1.15 gal/hr | 2.3 gal/hr |
| 22 kW | 140 cu ft/hr | 280 cu ft/hr | 1.6 gal/hr | 3.2 gal/hr |
| 48 kW | 275 cu ft/hr | 550 cu ft/hr | 3.2 gal/hr | 6.4 gal/hr |
10-Year Fuel Cost: NG vs Propane
Utility-fed. Never runs out. Cheapest per hour.
Off-grid. Tank required. Higher per-hour cost.
FINDING
10-year fuel savings with natural gas: roughly $1,615. However, if you do not have NG service, running a new line ($3,000 to $5,000) may offset the savings. Check current propane pricing at propanecostpergallon.com.
Propane Tank Sizing
| Tank Size | Install | Refill | 22kW @ 50% | 22kW @ 100% |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 250 gallon | $800 - $1,200 | $550 - $700 | 130 hrs (5.4 days) | 65 hrs (2.7 days) |
| 500 gallon | $1,200 - $2,000 | $1,100 - $1,400 | 260 hrs (10.8 days) | 130 hrs (5.4 days) |
Usable capacity is approximately 80% of tank size. Top off tanks before storm season; prices spike during outages.